Personal Property in a Divorce

Dinnerware and Other Personal Property in a Divorce
Dinnerware is Personal Property
Personal Property in a Divorce: Definition

Personal property in a divorce is effectively everything except real estate.  This includes: cars, financial assets, and household goods.

More specifically, “Personal property is the belongings of an individual, excluding any real estate property or other buildings. Generally includes tangible and intangible assets of an individual.” – Black’s Online Law Dictionary, 2nd.

However, in a divorce cars and financial assets are each dealt with individually.  They are typically much higher in value than household items, so this makes sense.

“Personal property” in a divorce typically is a lumped term that focuses on household items.  This is typically everything that’s in the house but not attached to the house.

How Personal Property is Viewed and Dividing by Value

First off, if a piece of personal property is particularly valuable, spouses examine it separately, like the cars mentioned above.  Some other examples include: expensive jewelry, tool sets and equipment, and gun collections.

However, most property in the home has “garage sale value”.  In other words, if it were appraised, it would be appraised at “what would it sell for at a garage sale?”  Commonly used household goods depreciate significantly after purchase and just aren’t often worth that much.

Also, courts don’t like dealing with personal property disputes.  The items often have minimal value.  It can also be labor intensive for the court, whose time is very valuable, to go line by line of property.  Think about how many items are in a home.

Often, if spouses can’t reach an agreement, the court will submit that dispute to arbitration.  In that case the parties attend a separate proceeding to argue who should get what personal property.

So, it may seem fair to assign each item a value and then divide.  However, in practice this can be more cumbersome than it’s worth.  Here are some alternatives.

Other Reasonable Ways to Divide

Often, when spouses understand how little household goods are worth this can defuse these disputes.  In that context, here are some useful methods to resolve personal property disputes:

“What’s Fair?”  In this case, the couple can each make a list of what he or she wants.  The departing spouse can make a list of the items he or she wants to take.  Each uses whatever criteria each spouse values.  It can be based on ballpark values, how much each likes the property, sentimental value, or any other criteria.  Both spouses may get what’s most important to him or her.

“What does each of us need?”  This is the ultimate practical view.  One spouse will be moving to a new home.  That departing spouse will need to furnish that home.  It makes sense for each spouse to figure out what he or she needs in their home after a split.  If there is a shortfall, this can be fairly balanced as well.  Then, have each spouse get what he or she needs for the new living arrangement.

For other divorce or family law questions, please consult the list to the left or the FAQ page.  If you’re interested in retaining an attorney to help you, please feel free to contact my office for a consultation using the contact information on the left or the contact form on the Majeski Law home page.